Australia: Non-existent goods not covered by marine cargo insurance
The facts in the English High Court decision in Engelhart v Lloyds Syndicate 1221 (2018)2 Lloyds Rep. 24 should cause concern to anyone involved in the international carriage of goods by sea, whether as traders or insurers. Engelhart shows that to cover financial losses that do not result from physical loss or damage, the open cover cargo policy must contain clear words to that effect.
The claimant's first shipment of copper ingots to a consignee in China arrived but the second had never been shipped, and there was no cargo to be physically lost or damaged. The losses were therefore treated as economic losses due to the cargo owner's acceptance of fraudulent documents in the expectation that they covered physical goods.
Cargo interest's argument that physical loss claims included circumstances where an Assured had been defrauded into taking out documents of title for non-existent goods was not accepted.
Given the prevalence of cybercrime and the ease with which it appears to be possible to insinuate fraudulent documents into international trading and carriage of goodstransactions, it would be appropriate for insurers, insureds and brokers to review their policy wordings to ascertain whether they would be covered.
The need for heightened security and to use processes such as Blockchain are becoming ever more significant. Also, an international liability regime that permits paperless trade, such as the Rotterdam Rules, should be brought into international usage as a matter of urgency.
Stuart Hetherington, Partner, Colin Biggers & Paisley
Link to original article: https://www.cbp.com.au/insights/insights/2019/january/non-existent-goods-not-covered-by-marine-cargo-ins
Search ADVOC News
We need 15 minutes of your time to help you and us! We’ve teamed up with leading design and architectural company S… https://t.co/twUoLheTkU
Pensions, like all assets need to be considered when negotiating a settlement on divorce or dissolution. There are… https://t.co/G7vAxmINlu
Recently, Angola's Government initiated a process to revise its Industrial Property Law. In recognising these steps… https://t.co/mELQu424OH
North Somerset Council call for sites to inform Local Plan 2038 https://t.co/8az2Nt5wqv
Here is the seventh post in our series of bitesize articles, focusing on practical points arising from the introduc… https://t.co/Q2VJR7uuKw